DIRE STRAITS
You're
free to go, but not your computer
By Anil
Netto
It's a
sign of the times. A Malaysian opposition activist has been released
after spending a day in jail, but his computer has now been taken
into custody.
It is
the latest in a series of incidents over the past week that illustrates
just how much the Internet is influencing public opinion and unnerving
the authorities.
When Prime
Minister Mahathir Mohamad mooted the futuristic-sounding Multimedia
Super Corridor in the mid-1990s, he could scarcely have imagined
that information and communications technology would be used by
the likes of Raja Petra Kamaruddin to mold critical public opinion.
Raja Petra
heads an effort to mobilize public opinion, both domestic and
international, in a bid to free jailed former deputy premier Anwar
Ibrahim. He runs the Free Anwar Campaign (FAC) website, reporting
on new campaign initiatives and reformasi protests both locally
and internationally. His FAC website, the only "official" campaign
site, unlike the hugely popular but anonymous reformasi websites,
draws about 20,000 hits daily, he says.
Given
the sustained reformasi protests and the high stakes involved,
Raja Petra's detention was perhaps not unexpected. But it was
telling that the authorities released him less than 24 hours later
and then confiscated his computer's central processing unit (CPU)
- surely a recognition of the Internet's ability to sidestep Malaysia's
tight media controls.
"It [the
CPU] will probably be in custody for a long time," Raja Petra
told Asia Times Online. "They are trying to establish that I am
the one behind the FAC. They need to link me to the website."
Even while
Raja Petra was in custody, the Free Anwar Campaign website was
still being updated, informing visitors of Raja Petra's arrest.
"So they [the police] know that I'm not alone," he says. "They
want to know who else is in the network." He says the police are
probably also trying to put names and faces to the other anonymous
reformasi webmasters.
Raja Petra,
now out on a bail guarantee of 5,000 ringgit (US$1,317) has to
report back to the police on March 21 to find out whether he will
be charged. He believes he is being investigated for possible
"sedition" for the postings on the FAC website. He was among eight
others, including his wife, who were detained on March 6 after
a group of about 50 people held a candlelight vigil outside the
Dang Wangi police station in Kuala Lumpur in support of a colleague,
Ezam Mohammad Nor, who was arrested a day earlier.
The FAC
is not the only website to have drawn unwelcome attention in the
past few days. On the same day the nine were detained, two threatening
e-mails were received by the chief executive of another website,
the independent news portal Malaysiakini. A Malaysiakini report
said the e-mails to Premesh Chandran were "believed to be linked
to the recent allegations that the news website was funded by
controversial currency speculator George Soros".
In recent
weeks, Malaysiakini has been singled out for attacks from sections
of the mainstream media and from several government officials
for allegedly obtaining financing from Soros, a charge the website
refutes. Mahathir has blamed Soros for triggering the regional
economic crisis in 1997.
Even postings
on discussion groups are monitored. A Universiti Malaya lecturer,
associate professor Chia Oai Peng, found herself in trouble when
she was ordered by the vice chancellor on February 6 to explain
her Internet postings on the controversy surrounding a Chinese
vernacular school in central Selangor state. Some 70 pupils at
the Damansara Chinese school are holding out against an Education
Ministry directive closing down the school and relocating its
pupils to another Chinese vernacular school farther away.
Chia,
who was once a PTA member of Damansara school, was reported as
saying she posted her messages to correct some erroneous information
on the school controversy. On March 8, about a dozen Internet
discussion groups threw their support behind her.
Meanwhile,
a leader of the Youth wing of the United Malays National Organization
(Umnno) has lodged a police report against a posting on the Laman
(Website) Reformasi, which he said threatened his safety. Umno
Youth assistant secretary Zulkifli Mohd Alwi made the police report
in Kuala Lumpur on March 7, claiming that the opposition National
Justice Party (Keadilan) had "threatened" him by posting his house
address and car registration numbers on the Laman Reformasi website.
Laman
Reformasi is the standard-bearer of a host of anonymous reformasi
websites clamoring for political and economic reforms. The website
has even criticized certain Keadilan leaders in the past. Zulkifli
claimed that the threat in the website had warned him "to beware
and not to regret if anything bad happened in his house".
Laman
Reformasi has been critical of an earlier police report by Zulkifli
which led to Ezam's arrest on March 5. Zulkifli made that report
claiming that a pro-government Malay daily on Sunday had reported
that Ezam was planning demonstrations to "topple" the government,
a charge Ezam denies.
The heightened
scrutiny of the Internet is a fairly new development and an implicit
recognition of the medium's effectiveness in shaping public opinion.
Only last year, the authorities cracked down on critical Malay
print publications. But this time the focus appears to have shifted
towards critical websites and discussion groups, which have come
under intense scrutiny. Though only some 10-15 percent of Malaysians
have access to the Internet, its reach is wider given that news
from the Web invariably spreads by word-of-mouth to other Malaysians.
In the
1999 general elections, the ruling coalition won a clutch of parliamentary
seats with razor-thin majorities in Malaysia's first-past-the-post
system. If hundreds of Malaysians in each of the country's 193
parliamentary seat are exposed to more critical Internet news
exposing abuse of power, the political equation could easily tilt
away from the ruling coalition. If the computer in custody is
any indication, that is a possibility that has not been lost on
the ruling coalition.
AsiaTimes
Online
|